Although "The Prophet Motive" was the third episode to air on CBS, I'd argue that it was the one that set the template for the episodes they chose. As it was one of the episodes to have been "previewed" (as far as I'm concerned, to have premiered) on The Disney Channel in early '94, it's easy to imagine, given Stones' account of CBS' selection process, the network people saying, "We like that one! We want it! And more like it!"
What exactly distinguishes the CBS episodes? They tend to have a darker, thicker tone; the magic, the monsters, and the ancient temples, objects of power, and prophecies were more primordial, menacing, and potentially devastating. The action was more highly charged and the set pieces were more imposing. If -- n the most general sense -- the syndication episodes were pop-rock, the CBS episodes were heavy metal.
That is not to say that there weren't syndication episodes of a nature comparable to the CBS ones. I want to be very careful in stressing that the syndicated and network episodes were NOT two separate series. (And while I'm at it, despite what Wikipedia and other online episodes lists will tell you, the fall '94 CBS episodes were NOT "season two". They were part of season one.) The fact that CBS picked episodes that Stones didn't expect them to indicates that at least the earliest CBS episodes were produced as any other episode would be. If CBS hadn't been a part of the picture, most if not at all of the 13 fall '94 CBS episodes would've been produced anyway, and instead would've just first showed up on The Disney Afternoon instead.
Those stipulations out of the way, let's get down to the meat of this episode itself, and what specifically distinguishes it besides just tone and narrative style. The opening is visually made up of a series of stills designed to look like ancient paintings depicting the day's epic myths of apocalyptic, furious battles between (what could be) gods and beasts. These images are accompanied by an eerie score and a voiceover narrative delivered in ominous, deep tones with almost a hushed reverence. This is nothing like anything seen in the three early `94 Disney Channel "preview premieres" that had preceded it.
The opening narrator turns out to be, of course, Phasir, who makes his debut here. (Well, that's arguable. I am very happy that this episode technically aired before "Do the Rat Thing", which premiered in syndication before CBS' first airing of "The Prophet Motive". I suppose it doesn't matter, as in "Rat Thing", Phasir only appears briefly before Jasmine and Iago, and Jasmine didn't meet Phasir in "Prophet" and Iago doesn't give any clear indication in either if he recognizes Phasir or not. But still, this means that -- again, this is a technicality, because by and large, the Disney Channel airings don't seem to be considered as having "counted" -- no Aladdin episodes premiered out-of-order continuity-wise, as was the case with Darking Duck. Er, obsessive much, Ryan?) Episodes in which Phasir is tied into the plot -- rather than just giving a prophecy or overseeing events to confirm that they "happened as they were meant to" -- together form what at least I consider the closest Aladdin ever got to having a series mythology. One could say that Mozenrath has his own mythology unto himself, but he never really transcended the function of recurring villain. By the same token, what we know of Phasir's backstory -- his relationship with his brother Fashoom and his connection to Mirage -- are his own business (if you get what I mean), in all of his appearances, some to greater extent, there was the implication that he had particular cause to be concerned with our heroes' destiny. In some cases, there were cryptic suggestions that he knew something them that they didn't. Nothing ever came of this and his few appearances are only loosely tied together, but the semblance of some sort of series "mytharc" (to use an X-Files fandom term) was for me exciting enough and always one of the most interesting aspects of the series.
Besides the more "hardcore" approach of "The Prophet Motive", what makes it typical of CBS is Phasir himself. Although he appeared in two episodes that premiered in syndication ("Do the Rat Thing" and "The Sands of Fate"), all of the "mytharc"-leaning Phasir episodes ("The Prophet Motive", "Eye of the Beholder", and season two's "While the City Snoozes") seemed to be the purview of CBS. His aforementioned syndication appearances affirm that we're talking one and only one TV series here, but I can't really get around that Phasir-plus-the "heavy metal" approach is a formula I associate with the CBS episodes. Notably, the voiceover-and-mythological ancient paintings intro motif was reused a couple of more times for I believe only CBS episodes.
In truth, there isn't much to this episode's plot -- it's a very straightforward, even bare-bones narrative dressed up in a bombastic, explosive package.It boils down to: Abis Mal and Haroud abduct Carpet to use him to get to the location of a long-lost treasure. Aladdin and the king pursue the villains to rescue their friend, are captured, have all escaped by the time they arrive at the treasure's location, where a giant monster statue comes to life, threatening the heroes and the villains, but the heroes get away and the bad guys get their comeuppance by not acquiring the treasure. This really could've been done without Phasir and the prophecy he delivers to Aladdin at the beginning of the episode and that hangs over the gang's head throughout the adventure. But the mystical, esoteric nature of Phasir and the way that the prophecy facilitates a stronger tension and sense of imminent mortal danger throughout the episode are really what give the episode more of that edge and fieriness that bring it to the soaring heights of your typical CBS episode. For instance, without the prophecy, we wouldn't have that (literally) edgy little Act One cliffhanger where Al and Jas almost get impaled on jagged rocks. And the literal skeleton key is more typical of the Saturday morning episodes; they were more grisly, by children's TV standards. I dunno, I just like the episode. It's cool, you know? The flying ship, the exterior of Fashoom's cloud-borne palace, and the treasure room inside are particularly striking.
The only thing I really dislike about the episode is Fashoom's character design, which I find goofy and just kind of ugly. You may argue, "But a giant brute should be ugly", but I guess it's that they erred on the goofy side.
This is technically Abis Mal and Haroud's first appearance (although something about "Air Feathered Friends", the first Disney Afternoon episode, gives it a "pilot" vibe and feels like it was intended to establish their part in the series). It's interesting to see such mundane villains brought into these larger-than-life affairs. Although they do get involved with magic and other big-stage things in many of their other episodes, those tend to be as a whole more comedic outings. The interplay between the two is as funny as ever, with some downright classic asides from Haroud when obeying Mal's orders to sew Carpet to the mast.
(Abis Mal discovering that he does not have that certain special touch that Scrooge McDuck does.)
Iago's cynical, "everyone has some sort of angle, since I always do!" reaction to Phasir ("I smell a RIPOFF!!!") is a great character moment. And unlike last time in "Fowl Weather", Jasmine isn't just sort of along for the ride and kind of naggy -- here, she's just as alert, on top of things, quick-witted, athletic, brave, and capable as Aladdin, if not more so. They play off of each other much better when they're presented as of the same "type".
The episode is what it is -- the Aladdin episode equivalent of a big-screen Star Wars-type popcorn flick. It works for me.
Genie Watch: The G-man obliviously remaining in buoy form and for a good while after he, Aladdin, and Jasmine have been "netted", not taking any initiative to free them, is excruciating to witness. It definitely recalls when he stayed in ostrich form just for the hell of it in "Mudder's Day" while he and the rest of the gang were swept down the raging current of the underground river that brought them to the realm of the Al Muddy, another Genie-chosen course of action that spurred much *facepalming*.